Histomat: Adventures in Historical Materialism

'Historical materialism is the theory of the proletarian revolution.' Georg Lukács

Saturday, January 31, 2015

C.L.R. James on Winston Churchill - Tory War-dog


Winston Churchill - a reactionary prize-fighter for the British ruling class

...Long before 1939, when the outbreak of war saved his career, Winston Churchill had established himself as the most discredited, the most untrustworthy, and the most irresponsible of all the senior politicians in England. The rulers of Britain did not take him seriously on the politics of war because, except for his capabilities as a war minister, they did not take him seriously on anything except his capacity to make a serious nuisance of himself.

Churchill was born the son of Lord Randolph Churchill, a brilliant young nobleman who reached the post of Chancellor of the Exchequer and seemed headed for the premiership but wrecked his career by his erratic political behavior. His character was adequately summed up in the phrase “the boy who would not grow up.” It was the kind of heritage that a careful politician would take care to live down. It is characteristic of Winston Churchill that he lived up to it.

He joined the army as a cavalry officer and thus began his lifelong and passionate interest in war. He became a war correspondent, was captured by the Boers and escaped. When he lectured in New York in 1906, at the age of twenty-six, he was billed as “the hero of five wars.” He was already actively interested in politics. In the early years of the century, liberalism seemed in the ascendancy in Britain. Churchill made a spectacular break with the Tory Party and joined the Liberals.

He became Home Secretary and distinguished himself by what is derisively known as the Battle of Sidney Street.  A group of foreign anarchists well supplied with arms refused to give themselves up to the police. Churchill converted a police operation into a battle. He went down himself to take charge of the “struggle” (or as privileged observer), was nearly killed and created a scandal among his colleagues and the sober-minded British people. In 1911 he went over to the Admiralty and there did his best work, preparing the fleet for 1914.

But the war of 1914 had no sooner begun than Churchill was at it again. A critical situation at Antwerp found Churchill, still head of the Admiralty, persuading the reluctant Sir Edward Grey to let him go to Belgium in person. He found himself as usual under fire. The battle stimulated him to offer, from Antwerp, his resignation from the Admiralty to take command of the British land forces at Antwerp. The transfer was not made but as one of his biographers (Philip Guedalla) says of the unsatisfactory outcome: “There was a vague feeling that Mr. Churchill’s restlessness might be to blame ... that it was Sidney Street over again ...”

By 1915, despite his competence, he had lost his post at the Admiralty. He held other posts, but it is related of him that at one time while a minister in London he did most of the work in a chateau in France so as to be near the firing line. After World War I he was the moving spirit in the military intervention against Russia. It is known that in 1944 to keep Churchill from joining the cross-channel expedition the present king had to threaten that he would also join it if Churchill insisted on going; baffled here, nevertheless Churchill turned up with the invading army in the last stages of the victory against Germany.

That is the man. Every British politician knew him and his Napoleonic complex, his preoccupation with war and war preparations, his extraordinary capacity for making a fool of himself on critical occasions. Asquith, Prime Minister in 1914, wrote of him “Winston, who has got on all his war-paint, is longing for a sea-fight in the early hours of the morning to result in the sinking of the Goeben.” Someone who saw him at the beginning of the 1914 war remarked on his “happy face”...

In the cabinet reshuffle of 1936, everyone expected him to be included because of his audacity as a war minister. Baldwin left him out. Churchill writes: "He thought no doubt, that he had given me a politically fatal stroke, and I felt he might well be right.” He says too, “There was much mockery in the press about my exclusion.” Exactly. His career was always in danger. His adventures were the subject of perpetual mockery. We can now judge with a little more sense of proportion Churchill’s claim that on a question vital to the world he was the purveyor of wisdom to fatuous idiots and fouls. If the words idiot and fatuity, etc., were to be applied up to 1936, the chief candidate would have been Churchill himself.

Never at any time did he behave like a man who had a serious point of view, knew what was at stake and fought seriously for it. These erratic habits of his were intimately connected with the failure of his supposedly correct policy on the war. It was precisely during the time that he was supposed to be fighting this life-and-death struggle to prevent the unnecessary war, that Churchill showed that age had not withered nor custom staled the infinite variety of what the novelist, Arnold Bennett, called his “incurable foolishness” ... it is clear that to this day he is not fully aware of the folly of his procedure in relation to his war policy...

In 1931, British imperialism began the colossal, and as it has proved, the impossible task of reconciling India to British rule by binding the Indian bourgeoisie and the feudal lords to the British system. After Hitler’s accession to power in Germany this was an urgent task precisely because of the uncertain world situation. Churchill, however, for years rallied the worst of the Daily Mail type of Conservatives and led a struggle against Baldwin which for intemperance and unscrupulousness even he has rarely surpassed. He was ignominiously defeated as he was bound to be ... any level-headed capitalist politician could not but see that some sort of settlement and pacification of India was necessary for any British government that contemplated war.

 By the end of his battle of India, the Conservative Party had no use whatever for him. However by 1936 he had built around himself a little group around a policy he called “Arms and the Covenant,” the Covenant being the League of Nations. The sharpening international situation was giving weight to their attacks upon the policy of the Baldwin government. Nothing is more illuminating of what Britain’s rulers thought of Churchill than his account of how, all through his years of political exile, every British Prime Minister saw to it that he was well informed of the latest military and scientific developments; he was even placed on some of the most secret war committees. This explains his place in British politics. He was a kind of national strong-arm man who was kept well trained and in shape, for the day when blows were needed. Until then nobody wanted to have anything to do with him. And this book shows that no one had worked more assiduously to build this reputation than himself.

But perhaps, it may be said, that despite all his follies Churchill was right in his consistent opposition on the war issue. His book explodes that fable. Churchill’s opposition on the actual issue of the war was no different from his shrill opposition on other issues. He spoke with more authority perhaps on this, and he certainly impressed outsiders and the general public. But he did not impress the politicians and for one very good reason. They knew that they could have shut up his mouth at any time by giving him office. The measure of their contempt for him can be judged by the fact that eloquent and active as he was they refused to do this.

History is full of men who felt that a certain policy was essential to the life of their country or their class and fought for it to the end, reckless of victory, defeat or their personal fate. Such for instance was the uncompromising struggle of Clemenceau for leadership of France in the days of 1914-18 when the government was in such a crisis that at one lime his attacks upon the government sounded like treason to the bourgeoisie. No such mantle can be hung on Winston Churchill despite all the assiduous tailoring of Henry Luce. Churchill knows better than to make any great claims for himself on this matter. There are too many men alive who could tear him to bits if he tried to do this. It was not principled opposition which kept him out of the ministry in 1936 and thus saved him from getting himself as thoroughly compromised as Baldwin and Chamberlain. It was his bad reputation and habits...

Until the war came Churchill was nobody, played no heroic role, opposed the government but was always ready to enter it...But maybe Churchill did have the correct policy, if even he did not make any heroic battle for it. Now this is precisely what was in dispute all the time and is still in dispute. And here, above all, Churchill’s policy, in so far as he had a policy, seemed to his colleagues the quintessence and crown of his irresponsibility.

Let us try to get clear exactly what Churchill’s policy was not. First of all Churchill was not and today is no enemy of either dictatorship or fascism. He is an enemy of all who threaten the British Empire and the “pleasant life” he leads and refers to so often. That is all.

On January 30, 1939, this stern opponent of Chamberlain’s policy of appeasing the dictators wrote as follows:

“Up till a few years ago many people in Britain admired the work which the extraordinary man Signor Mussolini had done for his country. He had brought it out of incipient anarchy into a position of dignity and order which was admired even by those who regretted the suspension of Italian freedom.” (Step by Step, 1936-1939, by Winston Churchill, p. 285.)

On February 23, 1939 he wrote of Franco:

 “He now has the opportunity of becoming a great Spaniard of whom it may be written a hundred years hence: ‘He united his country and rebuilt its greatness. Apart from that he reconciled the past with the present, and broadened the life of the working people while preserving the faith and structure of the Spanish nation.’ Such an achievement would rank in history with the work of Ferdinand and Isabella and the glories of Charles V.”(Ibid, p.285.)

As far as the record goes in this book he makes an extraordinarily good case for himself on the question of the air-race with Germany. But that is not enough to build the pedestal for his statue. And beyond this it is difficult to find out exactly what at any precise moment, he concretely stood for....

From all this it must not be considered that Churchill is a negligible person. That would be stupidity. Put him in a war department, or give him a war to lead, and from all the evidence he is far above his colleagues, in energy, in knowledge, in attention to business and curiously enough, in tempering his audacity with sobriety of judgment. He has also developed another valuable gift. His famous sense of history is famous nonsense. He has none, as I shall show in a moment. What he does have in his head is the writings of the great British historians and the speeches of the great British orators. This and his single-mindedness, his operatic consciousness of playing a great role in historic conflicts, enable him at times to rise to great heights of rhetoric.

At times his words can be singularly effective, especially when people are frightened and bewildered by the complex class, national and international currents of modern war. Churchill has no doubts, as a bull in a China shop has no doubts. He has a great gift of phrase, and long training as a journalist gives him an eye for the salient facts in a military or political situation. At all points he is equipped for war, to shout for war, to glamorize past wars, to explain a war that is going on, to make new ones look like a defense of civilization.

Politically he is as stupid a reactionary as ever. The war was no sooner over than he aroused universal execration in Britain by saying on the radio that the victory of the Labour Party would mean a Gestapo for Britain. He himself lost thousands of votes in his own constituency.... It is a measure of the degeneration of our society that such a man should be its most notable spokesman; above all it is a scandal that he should be represented ... as a defender of democracy and civilization. In reality the evidence is thick ... that Churchill is not merely a conservative, but is today as ever a vicious reactionary.

A few examples will suffice... writing about Hitler in 1932 he uses these sentences: “I admire men who stand up for their country in defeat, even though I am on the other side. He had a perfect right, to be a patriotic German if he chose. I always wanted England, Germany, and France to be friends.” Hitler attacked Britain. That is all that concerned Churchill. But for that he would have admired him to this day... 

Admiration for dictatorship and military and feudal elements, racial arrogance, anti-Semitism, these and much more stare you in the face as soon as you shake yourself free of bourgeois propaganda ... It is one of the urgent tasks of the struggle against war to expose ... the pretensions of this reactionary prize-fighter to be a defender of democracy and civilization.

C.L.R. James, 'Winston Churchill - Tory war-dog', Fourth International, 10, no. 2 (February 1949), pp.41-46



See also this poem, Great Britain's Greatest Beast by Heathcote Williams and this piece - Winston Churchill: The Imperial Monster  

Labels: , , , , , ,

45 Comments:

At 8:29 am, Anonymous assignment help said...

Sidney Starr Is A Transsexual Female, Who Came Out Of The Closet And Told The "Hip Hop" World She Was Born Male. Sidney Has Taken Alot Of Hate And Backlash From Ugly People Who Don't Look Half As Good As Her. Each Man Wants To Be With Sidney Starr. On the off chance that Sidney Starr Never Came Out Of The Closet As A Trans Woman No One Would Ever Know She Was Born Male Because She Looks Like A Genetic Female. Everything about Sidney Starr Is Feminine.

 
At 12:01 pm, Blogger Nida Amber said...

I am fond of reading history and historical stories especially of ancient time. Reading historical stories is the demand of my work as I provide Content Writing Services UAE and you never know who give the historical topic to write on.

 
At 11:51 am, Blogger Unknown said...

Very informative and nice post and also great blog with pieces of information. Thanks for sharing and keep it up.
Essay Writing Service

 
At 1:48 pm, Anonymous college essay help UK said...

A debt of gratitude is in order for one is radiant posting! I unquestionably appreciated understanding it, you can be an incredible creator. I will make sure to bookmark your blog and unquestionably will return the not so distant. I need to support proceed with your incredible posts, have a decent end of the week.

 
At 5:15 am, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Law Dissertation Help if you are worried for you dissertation writing, visted our website , we have very qualified writers who are always available for you help..

 
At 10:33 am, Blogger Natalia Boss said...

Dissertation Writing Services of thedissertationwriters is remarkable in all over the UK and it is also very cheap in prices.

 
At 10:51 am, Blogger billygiil said...

I did enjoyed reading this content; I am bookmarking your blog and definitely will come back again The dissertation help is there for your help.

 
At 2:43 pm, Blogger eve green said...

Best Mattress
thanks for sharing it

 
At 9:36 am, Blogger John Smith said...

Thanks for reminding me
Security System Reviews

 
At 12:00 pm, Blogger Anasmith said...

If you are searching for Online Assignment Help UK then we are presenting you Assignment Writing Ace firm which provides online assignment services for the students who needed to complete their assignment in university. We are giving you the best quality work that your teacher or lecturer would be surprised and amazed. So don’t take stress of anything and contact us!

 
At 10:07 am, Blogger the soft roots said...

gps voice navigation best app for me to find real location and nearby places all over the world great work by developer site.

 
At 10:15 am, Anonymous learn Quran online said...

Good blog post. I certainly love this website. Continue
the good work! learn Quran online

 
At 7:40 am, Blogger Peak Updates said...

For reading and publishing amazing post visit: https://peakupdates.com

 
At 7:29 am, Anonymous Street View said...

amazing job i like it very much

 
At 8:08 am, Blogger Abdul said...

That is what exactly I was looking for like pinoy tv online. Thanks for the info. I ll be sure to bookmark
https://pinoylambingantv.me/

 
At 7:55 am, Anonymous Transparent Background said...

best work

 
At 7:13 am, Anonymous online video downloader said...

amazing job

 
At 11:00 am, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Get free best trending apps apk download

 
At 9:30 am, Anonymous trendingapps said...

Get free best trending appps download and enjoy your life. It has most amazing articles and different kind of trending apps

 
At 6:55 pm, Anonymous few fun land said...

Thank for sharing this post.

 
At 6:53 am, Blogger Abdul said...

Let check thispinoy lambingan network
Checkstock refix
.

 
At 12:22 pm, Anonymous Video dwonloader android apps said...

Get free best video downloader android apps and enjoy your life. It has most amazing articles and different kind of android app.

 
At 8:30 am, Anonymous Cool drawing idea said...

Cool drawing idea is one of the best channel for amazing cool drawing ideas! This channel is created to provide you with the most stunning and cool drawing ideas.

 
At 10:44 am, Anonymous stories for kids said...

Thanks for sharing this
I Really like this Post
few fun land

 
At 1:02 am, Anonymous Mobdro APK said...

Mobdro APK app

 
At 8:25 am, Anonymous LED Flashlight said...

Thanks for sharing

 
At 6:46 am, Anonymous Sports News said...

Good Article. Thanks for sharing

 
At 7:20 am, Anonymous Health Tips said...

Your article is attractive and informative. Thanks for sharing

 
At 11:23 am, Anonymous Multiple Stopwatch said...

Very informative and nice post with pieces of information. Thanks for sharing and keep it up

 
At 6:01 am, Blogger Shaikh Zahid said...

For vehicles over 3 years of age, the proprietor should take it to any RTA Customer Center or some other affirmed testing focuses. Vehicle Testing Dubai The vehicle should likewise finish the review assessment if the current proprietor isn't the first proprietor of the vehicle. Pay the vital charges. The vehicle testing charge in Dubai costs 150 AED.

 
At 11:04 am, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Stars: Tally erp 9 is proficient bookkeeping programming which is utilized in numerous organizations. Accounting System Software In Dubai It empowered us to do Accounting, Inventory Management with godowns the executives, Also uphold GST highlights, Check Printing and some more. In count Erp 9 You can Manage your deals and Purchase bills.

 
At 1:40 pm, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Churchill was conceived the child of Lord Randolph Churchill, a splendid youthful aristocrat who arrived at the post Best Trading Software Pakistan of Chancellor of the Exchequer and appeared to be set out toward the prevalence yet destroyed his vocation by his sporadic political conduct.

 
At 6:02 pm, Blogger blackfurcoat93 said...

Politically he is as moronic a traditionalist as anyone might think possible. The conflict was no sooner over than he black fur coat cropped stirred all inclusive repulsion in Britain by saying on the radio that the triumph of the Labor Party would mean a Gestapo for Britain. He, at the end of the day, lost huge number of votes in his own electorate

 
At 10:23 am, Anonymous Anonymous said...

He became Home Secretary and distinguished Cargo To Pakistan From Dubai himself by what is derisively known as the Battle of Sidney Street. A group of foreign anarchists well supplied with arms refused to give themselves up to the police. Churchill converted Cargo To Pakistan From Sharjah a police operation into a battle. He went down himself to take charge of the “struggle” (or as privileged observer)

 
At 4:35 pm, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Politically he is pretty much as doltish a conservative Leon S. Kennedy Jacket as anybody would might suspect conceivable. The contention was no sooner over than he blended comprehensive aversion in Britain by saying on the radio that the victory of the Labor Party High School Musical Jacket would mean a Gestapo for Britain. He, toward the day's end, lost tremendous number of votes in his own electorate

 
At 10:10 am, Blogger Geniuses said...

פנינה שפיגל

 
At 7:36 am, Blogger Abdul Samad Sheikh said...

Very informative post. I also read uae writers to enhance my knowledge

 
At 9:58 am, Blogger Ayesha Saeed said...

Very best informative posting. As i was looking for Logo design service so i just checked your post. I was really like it. Very readable post. please also post like this in future.

 
At 12:07 pm, Blogger jessciacarvin said...

Hey! Very Good topic you shared to us if any Student want to Hire a Content Writing Service contact us to avail yourself the chance to upgrade your academic result by our help

 
At 11:41 am, Blogger Bridgewater Limousine said...

Nice to see this post as I saw party bus rentals really helped me out on my last weekend trip!

 
At 3:53 pm, Anonymous Sara Ember said...

Oh great. Do u hear about replica handbags check it out lv neverfull black here!

 
At 10:30 am, Blogger Charbonnel said...

Despite Winston Churchill's initial disrepute, the outbreak of war in 1939 ultimately salvaged his political career, highlighting his indispensable role as a war minister. Much like the unexpected redemption, chocolate truffle in Dammam sweeten narratives, turning seemingly ordinary moments into delightful surprises.


 
At 8:13 am, Blogger Anna Thomas said...

"Churchill's upbringing was marked by the shadow of his father's political downfall. Just as history shapes individuals, let experienced fitout companies in Dubai help transform spaces to reflect stories of resilience and evolution."

 
At 5:07 pm, Blogger new evolution inter deco said...


The influence of family dynamics on individual trajectories is evident in Churchill's story, where despite promising beginnings, personal and political challenges intertwined. Just as attention to detail and adaptability are crucial in historical narratives, precision and flexibility define the work of fit out contractors in Dubai, crafting spaces that reflect both functionality and elegance.

 
At 11:27 am, Blogger Road Bridge said...

The power of singularly effective words is profound, particularly amidst the chaos and confusion of modern warfare's intricate dynamics. In the realm of road resurfacing contractors in Edmonton, clear communication can similarly calm uncertainties and guide projects through challenges with precision and clarity.


 

Post a Comment

<< Home