Histomat: Adventures in Historical Materialism

'Historical materialism is the theory of the proletarian revolution.' Georg Lukács

Monday, May 07, 2012

On the Hans Gruber / Golden Dawn controversy

Richard Seymour has a fine analysis of the Greek elections, which together with the defeat of Sarkozy signify a large scale popular rejection of the politics of austerity across Europe (whether the electorates of France and Greece will now actually get any kind of end to such politics is another matter), but while I am here I may as well clear up one controversy that has emerged as a result of the class polarisation across Europe in the context of the crisis - the rise of the far right in France and Greece - and in particular the rise of the neo-Nazi group Golden Dawn in Greece. Namely didn't Alan Rickman's character Hans Gruber mention the Golden Dawn group in the classic action film Die Hard?



Hans: The following people are to be released from their captors: In Northern Ireland, the seven members of the New Provo Front. In Canada, the five imprisoned leaders of Liberte de Quebec. In Greece, the nine members of the Golden Dawn movement...


John McClane: [listening on the radio] What the fuck?


Karl: [mouthing silently] Golden Dawn?


Hans: [covers the radio] I read about them in Time magazine...

In fact, despite rumours to the contrary and the imagined dialogue above, in fact Hans Gruber refers to a Sri Lankan group 'Asian Dawn' in Die Hard. It is important to clear stuff like this up. The more important question of course is how can the radical left in Greece and France now build on their recent successes to ensure that the politics of hope triumph over the Nazis' politics of despair. Here perhaps the anti-racist and anti-fascist campaigning taken in Britain by groups like Unite Against Fascism might serve as some sort of inspiration...

Labels: , , ,

43 Comments:

At 9:34 pm, Blogger OBloodyHell said...

Considering that the efforts of Europe to rein in overspending appear to have failed, the Left is fighting a losing battle with fascism. When the economy collapses because all the money has been borrowed and spent, the fascist will, as usual, appear to have the answers to the failures of the Left, in CREATING this mess. Having sold the people "you can have your cake, eat it, too, and never ever have to pay for it" in order to get, and keep, power, they can hardly turn around NOW and say "Oh, but we must economize JUuuuust a Bit".

Those fascist answers are ugly and not very positive for the fate of the next generation, but that seems to fit in with the cycles of history, anyway. :-/

The children in their adolescence and teen years now will, in time, curse the American boomers and their European counterparts for destroying the richest civilization humanity has ever known, and dumping an enormous mess right into their laps.

 
At 1:59 am, Anonymous Anonymous said...

The line from the script is "Asian Dawn," not "Golden Dawn." Your entire argument is erroneous on the grounds that you mistook the dialogue.

 
At 10:30 am, Blogger Ruben Wilson said...

This is the really great post, I like Fantastic Beasts Coat I am interested in reading this post.

 
At 1:14 pm, Blogger Robert said...

Totally grabbed my attention. I believe the basic component of a good article is the topic around which your article revolves. I have been an enthusiastic reader for over a decade, therefore, I look for something new every other day. In short, loved the article. Undoubtedly, a good read indeed!
Robin Hood Leather Jacket

 
At 9:52 am, Blogger Vince Salisbury said...

I like this information and you share good information with us i like and recommend mens classic leather motorcycle jacket, i hope you will share a lot of information with us in future.

 
At 3:08 pm, Anonymous William Jacket said...

Thanks for sharing such information with us. It was too useful and productive. Rocket endgame vest . Please keep posting such great work.

 
At 2:17 pm, Blogger kevin said...


I like this information and you share good information with us i
danezon.com

 
At 6:00 pm, Anonymous William Jacket said...

Thanks for sharing such information with us. It was too useful and productive. Evangeline Lilly Ant Man and the Wasp Jacket . Please keep posting such great work.

 
At 1:18 pm, Blogger beannar said...

I have read your article, it is very informative and helpful for me.I admire the valuable information you offer in your articles if you are looking for all these goes live just like animation movie go ahead delta extranet employees landing page - read moreyour website or blog goes live for the first time, it is exciting. That is until you realize no one but you and your

 
At 1:45 pm, Blogger jenifer sam said...

nice content you shared with us keep it up and sharing with us on this beautifull blog i offered to you yeah it is all about spotlighting inspiring content that is—you guessed it—on animation. Aside from the numerous videos posted daily, followers also have access to exclusive insight and analysis from animation of best 123movies go - TrueClassics guide. Content is categorized to make it easy to find information based on your focus. On Animation also provides information on industry events, useful tools and gadgets and training programs.

 
At 6:26 pm, Anonymous Leather Jacket black said...

Thanks for sharing such information on this, Premium Quality Men’s Black Leather Jacket appreciate your input in this regard.

 
At 11:20 am, Blogger Skinoutfits said...

Wow..Looking very nice. I also tried this recipe. I would like to share with my friends. Keep it up!!
Clay Jehson Hoodie

 
At 2:36 pm, Anonymous Maeve Wiley Fringe Jacket said...

Follow the latest trends and leave your impression on viewers mind wearing this titled Maeve Wiley Fringe Jacket. Buy it and enjoy flat 80% off on all items.

 
At 9:57 am, Anonymous William Jacket said...

Thanks for sharing such information with us. It was too useful and productive. Fallout 4 Elder Maxson Coat . Please keep posting such great work.

 
At 8:16 am, Blogger Skinoutfits said...

great informationtop gun maverick jacket

 
At 10:02 am, Blogger Skinoutfits said...

I read your post and I found it amazing! thank!
Tom Hardy Vest

 
At 11:34 am, Blogger SK said...

i am browsing this site daily and get nice facts from here all the time.

 
At 7:34 pm, Anonymous William Jacket said...

Thanks for sharing such information with us. It was too useful and productive. Rip Wheeler Black Jacket . Please keep posting such great work.

 
At 12:08 pm, Anonymous William Jacket said...

Thanks for sharing such information with us. It was too useful and productive. William Jakcet . Please keep posting such great work.

 
At 5:05 am, Blogger Cyrus Jenix said...

Thankyou for sharing this information. i will soon visit again.
elder maxson coat

 
At 7:10 pm, Anonymous William Jacket said...

Thanks for sharing such information with us. It was too useful and productive. Kim Cattrall White Cotton Coat . Please keep posting such great work.

 
At 12:11 pm, Blogger LerenJack said...

This is definitely useful information if you want to keep your contacts update and organized. Thank you! Halloween Jackets for Women

 
At 11:45 am, Anonymous home maintenance dubai said...

This Blog is very informative for us. Thanks for writing about it. In this article, some examples help me in applying in daily life. amazing You have explained each and everything very well in detail. I hope you will write more pieces which help us in our daily routines.

 
At 6:57 am, Anonymous rea leather jackets for kids said...

Grab the chance now before you miss out on the Stunning New York original Yankees leather jacket  for a discounted price and free delivery on "Real Leather Jackets," also known as "Rleatherjackets."

 
At 9:23 am, Blogger Mike Rooney said...

I found this as an informative and interesting post, so I think it is very useful and knowledgeable.
jack torrance jacket Replica


 
At 3:07 pm, Blogger Finn Foley said...

Congrats on sharing the app! It looks like you've inspired others to share their apps with others. Have a great weekend! rip wheeler cotton jacket

 
At 4:38 pm, Blogger Elizabeth Lail said...

Embrace the audacity and self-assurance that the Red Hood Jacket Vest 2 in 1 exudes to make an impact everywhere you go.

 
At 2:43 pm, Blogger Finn Foley said...

Your tutorials are a fountain of ideas. Kill Em With Comedy Hoodie

 
At 2:45 pm, Blogger Finn Foley said...

Your teaching inspires progress. Kill Em With Comedy Hoodie

 
At 2:48 pm, Blogger Finn Foley said...

Your tutorials create a positive impact. Kill Em With Comedy Hoodie

 
At 2:50 pm, Blogger Finn Foley said...

Your guidance encourages exploration. Kill Em With Comedy Hoodie

 
At 2:57 pm, Blogger Finn Foley said...

Your expertise paves paths to success. Kill Em With Comedy Hoodie

 
At 2:15 pm, Anonymous John Baker said...

Proper drainage and excavation east Brunswick NJ
are the unsung heroes of a solid construction project. Without these essential processes, foundations can be compromised. Ensuring precision in drainage and excavation guarantees the longevity and stability of any structure.

 
At 3:38 pm, Anonymous arsenal jackets said...

Fair here to examined this astonishing article. Great to here the instructive web journal nowadays. Much obliged to share this amazing location.

 
At 2:46 pm, Blogger Costume Style said...

I think this is an informative post and it is very useful and knowledgeable. therefore, I would like to thank you for the efforts you have made in writing this article.taylor swift alot going on at the moment

 
At 4:37 pm, Blogger bindubabu123 said...

Looking for property for sale phuket? Explore a diverse range of real estate options in Phuket, Thailand, including luxurious villas, beachfront condos, and scenic land plots. Whether you seek a serene retreat or an investment opportunity, Phuket offers an array of properties to suit your preferences. With its stunning beaches, vibrant culture, and booming tourism industry, owning a piece of property in Phuket promises both lifestyle benefits and potential financial returns. Discover your dream property for sale in Phuket today and embark on a journey to tropical living or investment success.

 
At 7:21 am, Blogger kevinlevin said...

Beth Dutton's purse adds a touch of sophistication to her fierce character. Find similar styles for your own bold look.
beth dutton purse

 
At 9:25 am, Blogger TheLeatherMerchandise said...

Damar Hamlin's Super Bowl jacket sparked debate with its bold design, reflecting his personal beliefs.
Site: Super Bowl jacket

 
At 10:09 am, Blogger Linda Walters said...

Huge Ryan Gosling fan here! Scored The Fall Guy Black & Yellow Varsity Jacket from America Jackets and I'm obsessed.

 
At 3:44 pm, Anonymous Anonymous said...

The Enchanting Beauty of Flowers on Walls

"Indulge in the enchanting allure of flowers blossoming on walls! This captivating concept effortlessly brings nature's charm indoors, casting a spell of serenity and elegance. The delicate petals and lush foliage create a visual symphony that soothes the senses and uplifts the soul. It's like walking through a magical garden right in the comfort of your own space. Whether adorning a living room, bedroom, or event venue, these floral accents infuse every corner with timeless beauty and grace. Embrace the enchantment and let your walls bloom with everlasting splendor!"

 
At 2:32 pm, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Exploring Real Estate in Phuket: A Paradise Investment Opportunity

Uncover the potential of Phuket real estate: A Paradise Investment Opportunity invites exploration into one of Southeast Asia's most coveted markets. Whether you're considering residential properties or commercial ventures, Phuket promises lucrative prospects amidst its scenic beauty and thriving tourism industry.

 
At 1:32 pm, Anonymous Anonymous said...

"The Vanishing Threads: Exploring Discontinued Fabrics' was like uncovering buried treasure within the textile industry. The narrative skillfully unraveled the stories behind discontinued fabrics, highlighting their evolution and eventual obscurity. Each thread of history woven into the fabric of the book resonated with nostalgia and curiosity, inviting readers to reflect on the changing dynamics of fashion and consumer trends. It's a compelling reminder of the intricate interplay between innovation and tradition in the world of textiles."

 
At 12:44 pm, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Malia Baker quilted jacket from his "Delirious" stand-up special is a legendary piece of comedy fashion. Tight, shiny, and undeniably bold, it became a symbol of Murphy's outrageous stage persona.

 

Post a Comment

<< Home